Judicial
Supreme Court sides with police officers in two qualified immunity cases
The Supreme Court sided Monday with police in two cases in which plaintiffs claimed officers used excessive force, overturning separate lower court rulings that had allowed the officers to be sued for civil rights violations.
In two unsigned opinions, the court stressed police are entitled to be shielded from liability unless it is “clear to a reasonable officer” that their actions are unlawful. In both cases the court ruled that the officers were entitled to qualified immunity, the legal doctrine that protects police from liability for civil rights violations in many circumstances.
In one case, the Supreme Court overturned a lower court ruling that found an officer in California who placed his knee on a prone suspect could be sued. In another, it overturned a lower court ruling that two police officers in Oklahoma could be sued because their actions before a fatal shooting escalated the potential for violence.
Qualified immunity is a legal doctrine, developed by the courts, that shields law enforcement from liability for constitutional violations including allegations of excessive force. In recent years, legal scholars, lawmakers and judges have criticized the doctrine, arguing that it is not grounded in the proper legal authorities and too often shields officials from accountability.
Under existing precedent, an officer is not liable, even if he or she violates the Constitution, unless it was “clearly established” by prior cases that the conduct at issue was unconstitutional. Critics say that bar is too high and forces those claiming excessive force to search for a prior case with nearly identical facts.
-
Executive3 days ago
The Hunters Have Now Become The Hunted: Their Cruelties Are Swelling The Ranks Of The People Worldwide!
-
Constitution3 days ago
CHAPTER 9: Norman Dodd Interview Space Is No Longer the Final Frontier––Reality Is [upcoming release April 2024]
-
Clergy2 days ago
Why Do The American People Let The Corrupt Media & Politicians Set The Propaganda Narrative – Speak On Their Behalf
-
Executive5 days ago
Biden ballot woes continue
-
Entertainment Today3 days ago
Civil War (2024) – an incomplete prediction
-
Education2 days ago
CHAPTER 10: Objective Reality Is Required for a Free Society Space Is No Longer the Final Frontier—Reality Is [upcoming release May 2024]
-
Human Interest2 days ago
Idaho prepares to defend its abortion ban
-
Civilization5 days ago
President Biden Must Not Encourage Illegal Mass Migration From Haiti